Publication Ethics

 
 
 
Publication Ethics
Journal of Ethnomedicine and Medical Wellness (JEMEDWELL)
COPE ICMJE Helsinki WAME DOAJ KEPK
Editorial Commitment

JEMEDWELL is committed to ensuring that advertising, reprint, or other commercial revenue has no impact or influence on editorial decisions. We adhere to the standards and guidelines established by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE), the World Association of Medical Editors (WAME), and the Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ).

All parties involved in publishing — authors, peer reviewers, and editors — are expected to uphold these ethical standards. Violations will be handled according to COPE's established flowcharts and guidelines.

Section 1
Author Responsibilities
 
Originality & Plagiarism

Authors must ensure that their work is entirely original. Any use of others' work or words must be appropriately cited. All manuscripts are screened using Turnitin before peer review. A similarity index exceeding 25% (excluding references) will result in automatic rejection or required revision.

 
Authorship (ICMJE)

Authorship must meet all four ICMJE criteria: (1) substantial contribution to conception or design; (2) drafting or critically revising the manuscript; (3) approving the final version; (4) accountability for all aspects of the work. Guest, gift, and ghost authorship are strictly prohibited.

 
Data Integrity

Raw data must be retained for a minimum of 5 years after publication and made available for editorial review upon request. Fabrication, falsification, and selective reporting of results are forms of research misconduct that will lead to immediate rejection, retraction, and notification of the authors' institutions.

 
No Duplicate Submission

Simultaneous submission of the same manuscript to multiple journals is prohibited. Redundant or duplicate publication — republishing substantially the same work — is unethical. Authors must disclose any closely related submitted or published work. Violations are grounds for immediate rejection and blacklisting.

 
Conflict of Interest

All financial and non-financial conflicts of interest that could influence the results or interpretation of the manuscript must be disclosed. This includes funding sources, employment relationships, personal relationships, and competing interests. Disclosure must be made in the manuscript and in the submission system.

 
Corrections & Retractions

Significant errors in published work must be promptly reported to the editorial office. JEMEDWELL will issue a Correction for minor errors, an Expression of Concern when an investigation is pending, or a Retraction if findings are unreliable. Retracted articles remain visible online, marked clearly as retracted.

 
AI & Large Language Model (LLM) Disclosure Policy
New Policy 2024
Per COPE 2023 · ICMJE 2023 · Nature Portfolio 2023
1. AI tools (ChatGPT, Gemini, Copilot, etc.) cannot be listed as authors — authorship requires full ethical accountability which AI cannot bear.
2. Use of AI for content generation (text, figures, data interpretation) must be disclosed in the Methods and/or Acknowledgments section, including the tool name, version, and purpose.
3. Authors bear full responsibility for the accuracy of all AI-assisted content, including factual claims, citations, and data.
4. Undisclosed AI use in substantive content constitutes a form of plagiarism and will be treated as research misconduct.
5. AI used only for grammar/spelling correction requires a brief mention in the cover letter; no formal disclosure in the manuscript is required for this limited use.
Section 2
Reviewer Responsibilities
Strict Confidentiality

Manuscripts under review are confidential documents. Reviewers must not share, discuss, or use the manuscript's content for any purpose without explicit editorial permission. The identity of authors (in double-blind review) must not be sought.

Objectivity & Timeliness

Reviews must be objective, constructive, and evidence-based. Personal criticism of the author is inappropriate. Reviewers should respond promptly — if they cannot complete a review within the agreed timeframe, the editorial office must be notified immediately so an alternative reviewer can be appointed.

Conflict of Interest

Reviewers must decline to review manuscripts where they have a conflict of interest — including collaborations within the past 3 years, competing research interests, personal relationships with authors, or institutional affiliation. Any suspected conflict must be disclosed immediately to the Editor-in-Chief.

Expertise & Acknowledgment

Reviewers should only accept invitations for manuscripts within their area of expertise. If an assigned manuscript is outside their expertise, they must notify the editor immediately. JEMEDWELL acknowledges the voluntary contribution of reviewers in its annual Reviewer Acknowledgment published in the final issue each year.

Section 3
Editor Responsibilities
Fair & Unbiased Decisions

Editorial decisions are based solely on intellectual merit, originality, clarity, and relevance to the journal's scope — regardless of the authors' race, gender, religion, ethnicity, nationality, or institutional affiliation.

Editorial Independence

Editors are free from interference from publishers, advertisers, or institutional management. No editorial decision shall be influenced by commercial considerations. Editors have full authority over the final publication decision.

Confidentiality

Editors must maintain the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts and shall not disclose any information about a submission to anyone other than the corresponding author, reviewers, and editorial board members as appropriate.

Editor COI Management

Editors with conflicts of interest regarding a submitted manuscript (e.g., institutional collaboration, competing research) must recuse themselves and delegate the handling of that manuscript to another qualified editor or the Editor-in-Chief.

Section 4
Research Ethics & Human Subjects
Declaration of Helsinki — Mandatory Requirement

All research involving human participants must conform to the ethical principles set out in the World Medical Association Declaration of Helsinki (2013 revision). A statement confirming compliance, along with the ethics committee approval number and name of the approving institution (KEPK), must appear in the Methods section. Manuscripts lacking this information will not proceed to peer review.

Informed Consent (ICMJE)

Written informed consent must be obtained from all human participants before any study procedures. For case reports or case series, patient consent for publication is mandatory. Where consent was waived, the ethics committee decision must be explicitly stated and justified in the manuscript.

Patient Privacy & Anonymization

Patients have the right to privacy that should not be infringed without informed consent. Identifying information — including names, initials, hospital numbers, photographs, and any identifying details — must not be published unless the information is essential for scientific purposes and the patient gives written informed consent.

Traditional Knowledge & Indigenous Rights

Research involving traditional/indigenous knowledge or plant-based remedies must comply with the Nagoya Protocol and applicable national regulations. Consent from communities, proper attribution, and benefit-sharing agreements must be documented and disclosed. JEMEDWELL upholds respect for biodiversity sovereignty.

Animal Research

Research involving animals must adhere to the 3Rs principles (Replacement, Reduction, Refinement). The approval of the institutional animal care and ethics committee must be stated. Authors must describe how animal welfare was maintained throughout the study in compliance with ARRIVE guidelines.

Section 5
Misconduct, Corrections & Retractions

JEMEDWELL handles all allegations of research misconduct according to COPE's published flowcharts. Concerns may be raised by authors, reviewers, editors, readers, or third parties. All investigations are conducted with impartiality and confidentiality.

C
Correction (Erratum)

Issued when a portion of an otherwise reliable article is found to be misleading or inaccurate. The original article is linked to the correction notice. Used for honest errors by authors or publishers.

E
Expression of Concern

Issued when there is evidence of possible misconduct but a full investigation is pending, or when an investigation has not reached a definitive conclusion. Alerts readers while the inquiry continues.

R
Retraction

Issued when findings are fundamentally unreliable due to misconduct or honest error; plagiarism or duplicate publication is confirmed; or ethical approval was falsified. Retracted articles remain online, clearly marked. DOI is maintained for citation tracking.

W
Withdrawal

Pre-publication withdrawal is permissible if a significant error is discovered before the final version is published. Authors must formally request withdrawal with justification. Withdrawal after acceptance requires editorial board approval.

COPE Misconduct Flowcharts

JEMEDWELL follows COPE's standard procedures for investigating suspected misconduct. Refer to the COPE flowcharts for the step-by-step process used for different types of concerns.

View COPE Flowcharts
Section 6
Regulatory Framework
COPE
Committee on Publication Ethics — Standards for all parties
ICMJE
International Committee of Medical Journal Editors — Authorship & reporting
Declaration of Helsinki
WMA — Human subjects research ethics (2013)
WAME
World Association of Medical Editors — Editorial standards
DOAJ
Directory of Open Access Journals — Transparency & best practices
EQUATOR Network
Reporting guidelines — CONSORT, PRISMA, STROBE, CARE
KEPK
Komite Etik Penelitian Kesehatan — Indonesian health research ethics
COPE Flowcharts
Step-by-step guidance for handling misconduct allegations
Section 7
Useful Links for Authors, Reviewers & Editors
Questions about Publication Ethics?

If you have concerns about research or publication ethics — including potential misconduct by any party — please contact the editorial office. All communications are treated with strict confidentiality and are handled per COPE guidelines.